BIOTRONIK Statement on CardioMessenger II Cybersecurity
CardioMessenger devices form an essential part of BIOTRONIK’s remote monitoring system, enabling the secure transmission of critical patient and device data to the treating physician. As the company that pioneered remote monitoring, we have taken cybersecurity design seriously since 2001. It is integrated into our quality management system, all relevant business processes and prioritized at every step of the product life cycle.
Our cardiac implants do not accept programming modifications or commands via any form of long-distance communication. By design, it is technically impossible to transmit commands to our implants remotely which obviates the potential of reprogramming the patient's device and doing direct harm to the patient.
In October 2019, researchers at SINTEF provided a report to BIOTRONIK describing potential cybersecurity concerns associated with CardioMessenger II devices which are no longer available on the market. We would like to reassure patients, healthcare providers and physicians that these devices are safe and can continue to be used as intended.
As a result of the SINTEF report, we initiated a comprehensive analysis which determined that the cybersecurity questions raised did not have an impact on patient safety. Specifically, no CardioMessenger, past or current models, can modify an implantable cardiac device’s diagnostic or therapeutic functionality. This is a deliberate design feature to ensure patient safety. We shared our findings with the researchers who also agreed that “BIOTRONIK provided sufficient information to confirm that patient harm arising from the vulnerabilities is very unlikely.”1 In addition, the particular model concerned, the CardioMessenger II, is an older generation of the device that has since been superseded by the CardioMessenger Smart.
It is also important to note that there have been no cyberattacks or privacy breaches related to CardioMessenger. The Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) at the US Department of Homeland Security also confirm that “no known public exploits specifically target these vulnerabilities.”2 CardioMessenger devices are safe and, in fact, BIOTRONIK Home Monitoring has been shown to significantly reduce patient hospitalization3, stroke4 and mortality3.
We take cybersecurity extremely seriously at BIOTRONIK and we are strongly committed to providing safe and reliable cardiovascular devices that improve the lives of millions of patients. Our cybersecurity management process is carefully designed according to the recommendations of the US FDA’s guidance to identify and control risks in all relevant devices and systems. The BIOTRONIK Home Monitoring System is operated using an information security management system certified according to the international standard ISO/IEC 27001:2013. This information security management standard is the framework that guides BIOTRONIK in identifying, analyzing and addressing information risks. It also specifies the requirements for establishing, implementing and maintaining an information system and ensures security measures are constantly adapted in response to the changing cybersecurity landscape.
We will continue to monitor, test and analyze the safety of our devices and value the contributions of independent cybersecurity researchers in helping us to achieve this.
For any questions concerning BIOTRONIK devices, please contact us:
For patients: contacts us via this contact form.
For physicians and healthcare providers: product.support@biotronik.com
General enquiries: press@biotronik.com
References:
1. Coordinated Disclosure Statement: https://guillaumebour.fr/articles/security_testing_pacemaker_ecosystem/part_1_introduction_context_methodology/
2. CISA ICS Medical Advisory https://www.us-cert.gov/ics/advisories/icsma-20-170-05
3. Hindricks et al. European Heart Journal 2017, 38, 1749–1755.
4. Mabo P et al. European Heart Journal. 2012, 33.
About BIOTRONIK:
At BIOTRONIK, patient well-being is our top priority and has been for 60 years. BIOTRONIK is a leading global medical technology company with products and services that save and improve the lives of millions suffering from heart and blood vessel diseases as well as chronic pain. Driven by a purpose to perfectly match technology with the human body, we are dedicated innovators who develop trusted cardiovascular, endovascular and neuromodulation solutions. BIOTRONIK is headquartered in Berlin, Germany, and is represented in over 100 countries.
More Statements
-
Image
StatementBIOTRONIK Statement on the Publication ‘Security Testing of the Pacemaker Ecosystem’
The work ‘Security Testing of the Pacemaker Ecosystem’ was recently published as a master’s thesis, authored by Mr. Anders Been Wilhelmsen and Mr. Eivind Skjelmo Kristiansen. This publication investigates the state of cybersecurity of BIOTRONIK’s ICS 3000 – a programmer for BIOTRONIK implantable cardiac pacemakers, defibrillators and monitors that is used by healthcare professionals during the implantation procedure and follow-ups. ICS 3000 programmers were distributed between 2001 and 2012. In the publication, the authors report about several cybersecurity weaknesses such as: The central
-
Image
StatementBIOTRONIK Statement on “SweynTooth” Cybersecurity Vulnerabilities
The US Food and Drug Administration has issued a Safety Communication regarding a family of cybersecurity vulnerabilities known as SweynTooth, which may introduce risks for certain medical devices that use Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) wireless communication technology. If exploited, these vulnerabilities can allow unauthorized users to potentially cause a device to stop working, stop it from working correctly and/or bypass security to access certain device functions. The FDA has said it is not aware of any confirmed adverse events related to these vulnerabilities although software to exploit
-
Image
StatementStatement on the Cybersecurity of BIOTRONIK Solutions Following WIRED Magazine’s Article on Vulnerabilities in Pacemaker Programmer Systems
On August 9, WIRED magazine reported that researchers discovered cybersecurity vulnerabilities in the way pacemaker programmers connected to the software delivery network of a specified manufacturer. The researchers claim that “digital code signing”—the cryptographic validation of the legitimacy and integrity of software—is lacking in the manufacturer’s infrastructure, allowing an attacker to potentially take control of device programmers through malicious updates that can subsequently be spread to implanted pacemakers. 1 None of BIOTRONIK’s devices, programmers or networks are affected by
-
Image
BIOTRONIK Statement on the FDA’s Safety Communication “URGENT/11”
On October 1, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued a Safety Communication regarding a set of cybersecurity vulnerabilities, referred to as “Urgent/11” that — if exploited by a remote attacker — may introduce risks for medical devices and hospital networks. According to the communication: “These vulnerabilities may allow anyone to remotely take control of the medical device and change its function, cause denial of service, or cause information leaks or logical flaws, which may prevent device function.” These vulnerabilities exist in a third-party software component known as IPnet
-
Image
StatementBIOTRONIK Statement on the Log4Shell Vulnerability
The discovery of a high-severity vulnerability known as Log4Shell was disclosed publicly on December 9, 2021, while a related lower-severity vulnerability was disclosed on December 14, 2021. These vulnerabilities are present in a software library used by many servers worldwide (see Background for details). In light of this recent discovery, BIOTRONIK has carefully analyzed all of its provided services. The analysis concluded that the conditions for exploitation of the Log4Shell vulnerability and the related CVE-2021-45046 and CVE-2021-45105 vulnerabilities do not exist in any of BIOTRONIK’s
-
Image
StatementBIOTRONIK Statement on the Cybersecurity Updates Affecting Medtronic Implantable Cardiac Device Programmers
On October 11, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued a Safety Communication regarding cybersecurity updates affecting Medtronic implantable cardiac device programmers, based on an NCCIC Advisory. 1 According to the FDA’s communication, Medtronic is issuing a software update to address a safety risk caused by cybersecurity vulnerabilities associated with the internet connection in two models of programmers used to download software from the manufacturer’s software distribution network (SDN). Successful exploitation of these vulnerabilities would allow an adversary to influence this
-
Image
StatementBIOTRONIK Statement on the Medical Advisory and Safety Communication Regarding Medtronic’s Conexus Radio Frequency Telemetry Protocol
The Department of Homeland Security and the US FDA have issued a Medical Advisory and Safety Communication respectively describing two types of cybersecurity vulnerabilities affecting multiple Medtronic devices that utilize the Conexus telemetry protocol. BIOTRONIK utilizes substantially different protocols for both the clinical and the home environment. Moreover, by design, the remote communication system via BIOTRONIK Home Monitoring® does not have the functionality to transmit or alter therapeutic commands to the implant.